PART FOUR - Who Really Deserved the Cy Young Awards (2000-2013)?
Lessons Learned:
(1) 5-Time CYA Winner - Randy Johnson - Should Have Won Six Times.
(2) Mike Mussina - Not Roger Clemens - Was the Ace of the 2001 Yankees' Staff & the Best Pitcher in the AL.
(3) 2-Time CYA Winner - Roy Halladay - Should Have Won Four Times.
(4) 2-Time CYA Winner - Johan Santana - Should Have Won Three Straight Times.
(5) Brandon Webb was the Best Pitcher in the NL for Two Straight Years - Not Just Once.
(6) 16 Out of 28 Picks Had Highest WAR in Their League - Voters Are Catching On
CYA Winners & War Leaders (2000-2013):
2000 ( AL) - Pedro Martinez (11.7)
2000 (NL) - Randy Johnson (8.1)
2001 (AL) - Roger Clemens (5.6) - Mike Mussina (7.1)
2001 (NL) - Randy Johnson (10.0)
2002 (AL) - Barry Zito (7.2) - Roy Halladay (7.4)*
2002 (NL) - Randy Johnson (10.9)
(*Sure, this is very close - in favor of Halladay - but what makes this unusual - Halladay received nary a CYA vote.)
2003 (AL) - Roy Halladay (8.1)
2003 (NL) - Eric Gagne (3.7) - Mark Prior (7.4)*
(*Payback for a wrongly accused Cubs' fan - Bartman - 2003 NLCS.)
2004 (AL) - Johan Santana (8.6)
2004 (NL) - Roger Clemens (5.4) - Randy Johnson (8.5)*
(*Clemens - extremely overrated - Johnson - extremely underrated in '04.)
2005 (AL) - Bartolo Colon (4.0) - Johan Santana (7.2)
2005 (NL) - Chris Carpenter (5.4) - Roger Clemens (7.8)
2006 (AL) - Johan Santana (7.5)
2006 (NL) - Brandon Webb (7.0)
2007 (AL) - C.C. Sabathia (6.3) - Josh Beckett (6.5)
2007 (NL) - Jake Peavy - (6.2) - Brandon Webb (6.4)
2008 (AL) - Cliff Lee (6.9)
2008 (NL) - Tim Lincecum (7.9)
2009 (AL) - Zack Greinke (10.4)
2009 (NL) - Tim Lincecum (7.5)
2010 (AL) - Felix Hernandez (7.1)
2010 (NL) - Roy Halladay (8.3)
2011 (AL) - Justin Verlander (8.4)
2011 (NL) - Clayton Kershaw (6.5) - Roy Halladay (8.9)
2012 (AL) - David Price (6.9) - Justin Verlander (7.8)
2012 (NL) - R.A. Dickey (5.8) - Clayton Kershaw (6.2)
2013 (AL) - Max Scherzer (6.7) - Hisashi Iwakuma (7.0)
2013 (NL) - Clayton Kershaw (7.8)
Next: Who Really Deserved to Win the MVP Awards? Some Shocking Discoveries!
Exposing Donald Trump's Crimes Against the US Constitution & Humanity
Showing posts with label Cy Young Award. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cy Young Award. Show all posts
Saturday, June 21, 2014
Thursday, June 19, 2014
Cy Young Award Winners (1986 - 1999) - Who Really Deserved to Win?
PART THREE - Revising CYA History (1986 - 1999) - Lessons Learned:
(1) Never, Ever Vote for a Reliever
(2) Bob Welch Lost When He Should Have Won & Won When He Should Have Lost
(3) Teddy Higuera, Mark Gubicza, Ed Whitson, Kevin Appier & Jose Rijo Should Have Won One CYA
(4) Kevin Brown Should Have Won Two CYA's - Instead of None
(5) Orel Hershiser Should Have Won Two CYA's - Instead of Just One
(6) Roger Clemens Should Have Won Six CYA's - Instead of Just Five
(7) Maddux, Glavine & Smoltz Were Slightly Overrated - But Still Great
Who Should Have Won (1986 - 1999)? The Wins Above Replacement Leader (If Different Than The Winner) is Shown for Each Year - Therein Lies the Answer:
1986 (AL) - Roger Clemens (8.9) - Ted Higuera (9.4)
1986 (NL) - Mike Scott (8.4)
1987 (AL) - Roger Clemens (9.4)
1987 (NL) - Steve Bedrosian (2.5) - Bob Welch (7.1)
1988 (AL) - Frank Viola (7.7) - Tie: Mark Gubicza (7.7)
1988 (NL) - Orel Hershiser (7.2)
1989 (AL) - Bret Saberhagen (9.7)
1989 (NL) - Mark Davis (4.5) - Orel Hershiser (7.0)*
(*Back-to-back seasons with highest NL WAR among pitchers for the underrated Hershiser.)
1990 (AL) - Bob Welch (3.0) - Roger Clemens (10.6)*
1990 (NL) - Doug Drabek (4.2) - Ed Whitson (7.0)**
(*Perhaps the biggest travesty in the history of postseason awards - Compare Welch's numbers to Clemens' - At first glance, it looks like Welsh had the better season. Further glances would tell any reasonable voter quite the contrary was true.)
Win-Loss - Welch - 27-6 Clemens 21-6
ERA Welch - 2.95 Clemens - 1.93 (Over 1 run/9 innings lower!)
Shutouts Welch - 2 Clemens - 4
Games Started Welch - 35 Clemens - 31
Complete Games Welch - 2 Clemens - 7
Innings Pitched Welch - 238 Clemens - 228.1
Strikeouts Welch - 127 Clemens - 209
ERA+ Welch - 125 Clemens - 211
(**Yes, this is the same wild-eyed Ed Whitson whose previous claim to fame was going ballistic in an '84 shirt-ripping brawl in Atlanta - not only tangling with Braves players - but some of their bellicose fans, as well.)
1991 (AL) - Roger Clemens (7.9)
1991 (NL) - Tom Glavine (8.5)
1992 (AL) - Dennis Eckersley (2.9) - Roger Clemens (8.8)
1992 (NL) - Greg Maddux (9.2)
1993 (AL) - Jack McDowell (4.3) - Kevin Appier (9.2)
1993 (NL) - Greg Maddux (5.8) - Jose Rijo (9.3)
1994 (AL) - David Cone (6.8)
1994 (NL) - Greg Maddux (8.5)
1995 (AL) - Randy Johnson (8.6)
1995 (NL) - Greg Madux (9.7)
1996 (AL) - Pat Hentgen (8.5)
1996 (NL) - John Smoltz (7.3) - Kevin Brown (8.0)
1997 (AL) - Roger Clemens (11.9)
1997 (NL) - Pedro Martinez (9.0)
1998 (AL) - Roger Clemens (8.1)
1998 (NL) - Tom Glavine (6.1) - Kevin Brown (8.6)
1999 (AL) - Pedro Martinez (9.7)
1999 (NL) - Randy Johnson (9.2)
Wednesday, June 18, 2014
JUNE 18: 1966 - 1974 - 1976 - Brock's Birthday Celebrations
June 18 is Lou Brock's birthday - and for the first five seasons as a member of the St Louis Cardinals ('64 - '68), Lou's birthday brought good fortune to the Redbirds.
The Cardinals always managed to win on June 18 in that five-season span - despite the fact that the birthday boy himself hit a paltry .174 in those games (four hits in twenty-three at bats).
However, his one hit in '65 drove in a run, as the Cardinals beat the Braves by a score of 5-4.
He was just getting warmed up for next year.
Saturday, June 18, 1966 - At Busch Stadium II (Al Jackson - Starting Pitcher) - Opponent: Philadelphia Phillies (Bob Buhl - Starting Pitcher) - Attendance: 36,932
After the Phillies failed to score in the first-inning, Lou Brock led off the bottom of the first with an infield single - immediately stole second with Phil Gagliano batting - then scored on Gag Man's double. Curt Flood's single to left field moved Gagliano to third - who then scored when cleanup hitter Tito Francona grounded into a double play.
Dick Allen's fourth-inning solo home run gave the Phillies their first run of the game, cutting the Cardinal lead in half - 2-1.
The Phillies tied the game in the eighth-inning on a single, a sacrifice bunt, a wild pitch, a walk and a throwing errror.
In the bottom of the eighth, with two out, Brock greeted former teammate Roger Craig - now pitching for Philadelphia - with a tie-breaking home run. It proved to be a game winner after Jackson (6-5) retired the side in the ninth, for the complete game win. In his two innings of work, the Brock home run was the only hit (and run) allowed by Craig (2-1).
Star of the Game Lou Brock had three hits in four trips to the plate, stole a base, scored two of the three runs the Redbirds put on the board tonight - and of course, hit the clutch home run to win it.
Afterwards, Brock dutifully answered Harry Caray's post game Busch Beer-enhanced Star of the Game interrogatories - good for a complimentary Lucian-Picard watch for the speedy 27-year-old birthday boy.
Lou would go 0 for 9 on June 18, 1967 and '68, collectively - but it didn't matter. The Cards had plenty of good pitching in a 4-1 win over the Giants and a 1-0 shutout of the Cubs.
Alas, all good things must come to an end. For the Cardinals, Lou Brock's 30th birthday brought about a reversal of fortune - losing to the lowly expansion-Montreal Expos, 5-1. That game may have been an omen for the team heavily favored to play in a third straight World Series in '69. Not this year. In fact, the Cardinals would fail to reach the postseason for the rest of Lou Brock's career -which ended after the '79 season.
After that June 18 loss in '69, St Louis would go on to lose six of the next nine Brock birthday engagements - but two of the three games they won over that span were greatly aided by an aging Lou Brock's stellar birthday performance.
Tuesday, June 18, 1974 - At Busch Stadium II (Alan Foster - Starting Pitcher) - Opponent: San Francisco Giants (Ron Bryant - Starting Pitcher) - Attendance: 17,709
After a scoreless top half of the first-inning, Lou Brock opened the bottom half with a single, stole second while Ted Sizemore was busy striking out, stayed there after Ted Simmons flew out to center - then scored on Joe Torre's base hit to left field.
That was all the run support Foster (2-5) would need tonight, in blanking the Giants on five hits in nine innings - although they added an insurance run in the fourth - on a Mike Tyson RBI single.
Then, when Brock led off the seventh with his second single of the game, Elias Sosa came in to relieve Bryant. The 35-year old stolen base maestro then swiped his second bag of the game - later scoring from third on Sosa's bobble of a Jose Cruz grounder. Apparently, Sosa was distracted by Brock at third base, took his eye off the ball which clanked off his glove - and the Cardinals had their third and final run of the game.
For Bryant (2-8) - what a difference a year makes - a 24 game-winner in '73, he would win just three games in '74 - while losing 15. Somehow, the Cardinals thought he'd be a good addition to the team in '75 - so on May 9, 1979, they traded away outfielder Larry Herndon - who would go on to have a successful 14-year career - first with the Giants, then with the Detroit Tigers - as part of the '84 World Championship team - to acquire the over-the-hill Bryant - who was subsequently released on July 31, 1975 after a total of 10 innings pitched, an 0-1 record and an ERA of 16.00.
Friday, June 18, 1976 - At Busch Stadium II (Pete Falcone - Starting Pitcher) - Opponent: San Diego Padres (Randy Jones - Starting Pitcher) - Attendance: 14,501
The Cardinals overcame a 3-0 deficit by scoring four runs in the fourth-inning - and Lou Brock was right in the middle of everything - stirring things up with his bat and his speed - as usual.
After Don Kessinger singled to open the fourth for St Louis, Brock followed that up with a single to center - sending Kessinger to third. With Ted Simmons batting, Brock put himself in scoring position as well, by stealing second. With first base open, Jones decided to pitch to Simmons, who promptly lined a single to center, scoring both runners. Two outs later, Hector Cruz lined one off the left field wall, which managed to elude both the left fielder and center fielder long enough for Cruz to cruise all the way around for a rare inside the park home run.
After Falcone prevented any San Diego scoring in the fifth-inning, St Louis had a little lightning in a bottle in the bottom half of the fifth. With two out, Kessinger lined another single to center, bringing Brock to the plate. Lou then took the future 1976 NL Cy Young Award winner deep - not quite deep enough to go over the wall - but deep enough to hit high off the top of the wall - then elude both the right fielder and center fielder long enough for Brock to streak all the way around for another rare inside the park home run - the second in as many innings for the Cardinals.
Each team added single tallies in the sixth-inning to close out the scoring: St Louis 7 - San Diego 4.
Falcone (5-5) went the distance, handing Jones (12-3) a rare loss. Jones would be mediocre the rest of the season (10-11) - however, he still led the NL in wins, which was good enough to win his first and only Cy Young Award - although eight other NL pitchers were more deserving. Happens all the time.
Meanwhile, this would prove to be the last time Lou Brock would experience the thrill of victory on his birthday. The Cardinals as a whole, had little to be thrilled about in '76 - except maybe this one game, featuring not one - but two inside the park home runs in successive innings. Yes indeed. Happy birthday, Mr Brock.
The Cardinals always managed to win on June 18 in that five-season span - despite the fact that the birthday boy himself hit a paltry .174 in those games (four hits in twenty-three at bats).
However, his one hit in '65 drove in a run, as the Cardinals beat the Braves by a score of 5-4.
He was just getting warmed up for next year.
Saturday, June 18, 1966 - At Busch Stadium II (Al Jackson - Starting Pitcher) - Opponent: Philadelphia Phillies (Bob Buhl - Starting Pitcher) - Attendance: 36,932
After the Phillies failed to score in the first-inning, Lou Brock led off the bottom of the first with an infield single - immediately stole second with Phil Gagliano batting - then scored on Gag Man's double. Curt Flood's single to left field moved Gagliano to third - who then scored when cleanup hitter Tito Francona grounded into a double play.
Dick Allen's fourth-inning solo home run gave the Phillies their first run of the game, cutting the Cardinal lead in half - 2-1.
The Phillies tied the game in the eighth-inning on a single, a sacrifice bunt, a wild pitch, a walk and a throwing errror.
In the bottom of the eighth, with two out, Brock greeted former teammate Roger Craig - now pitching for Philadelphia - with a tie-breaking home run. It proved to be a game winner after Jackson (6-5) retired the side in the ninth, for the complete game win. In his two innings of work, the Brock home run was the only hit (and run) allowed by Craig (2-1).
Star of the Game Lou Brock had three hits in four trips to the plate, stole a base, scored two of the three runs the Redbirds put on the board tonight - and of course, hit the clutch home run to win it.
Afterwards, Brock dutifully answered Harry Caray's post game Busch Beer-enhanced Star of the Game interrogatories - good for a complimentary Lucian-Picard watch for the speedy 27-year-old birthday boy.
Lou would go 0 for 9 on June 18, 1967 and '68, collectively - but it didn't matter. The Cards had plenty of good pitching in a 4-1 win over the Giants and a 1-0 shutout of the Cubs.
Alas, all good things must come to an end. For the Cardinals, Lou Brock's 30th birthday brought about a reversal of fortune - losing to the lowly expansion-Montreal Expos, 5-1. That game may have been an omen for the team heavily favored to play in a third straight World Series in '69. Not this year. In fact, the Cardinals would fail to reach the postseason for the rest of Lou Brock's career -which ended after the '79 season.
After that June 18 loss in '69, St Louis would go on to lose six of the next nine Brock birthday engagements - but two of the three games they won over that span were greatly aided by an aging Lou Brock's stellar birthday performance.
Tuesday, June 18, 1974 - At Busch Stadium II (Alan Foster - Starting Pitcher) - Opponent: San Francisco Giants (Ron Bryant - Starting Pitcher) - Attendance: 17,709
After a scoreless top half of the first-inning, Lou Brock opened the bottom half with a single, stole second while Ted Sizemore was busy striking out, stayed there after Ted Simmons flew out to center - then scored on Joe Torre's base hit to left field.
That was all the run support Foster (2-5) would need tonight, in blanking the Giants on five hits in nine innings - although they added an insurance run in the fourth - on a Mike Tyson RBI single.
Then, when Brock led off the seventh with his second single of the game, Elias Sosa came in to relieve Bryant. The 35-year old stolen base maestro then swiped his second bag of the game - later scoring from third on Sosa's bobble of a Jose Cruz grounder. Apparently, Sosa was distracted by Brock at third base, took his eye off the ball which clanked off his glove - and the Cardinals had their third and final run of the game.
For Bryant (2-8) - what a difference a year makes - a 24 game-winner in '73, he would win just three games in '74 - while losing 15. Somehow, the Cardinals thought he'd be a good addition to the team in '75 - so on May 9, 1979, they traded away outfielder Larry Herndon - who would go on to have a successful 14-year career - first with the Giants, then with the Detroit Tigers - as part of the '84 World Championship team - to acquire the over-the-hill Bryant - who was subsequently released on July 31, 1975 after a total of 10 innings pitched, an 0-1 record and an ERA of 16.00.
Friday, June 18, 1976 - At Busch Stadium II (Pete Falcone - Starting Pitcher) - Opponent: San Diego Padres (Randy Jones - Starting Pitcher) - Attendance: 14,501
The Cardinals overcame a 3-0 deficit by scoring four runs in the fourth-inning - and Lou Brock was right in the middle of everything - stirring things up with his bat and his speed - as usual.
After Don Kessinger singled to open the fourth for St Louis, Brock followed that up with a single to center - sending Kessinger to third. With Ted Simmons batting, Brock put himself in scoring position as well, by stealing second. With first base open, Jones decided to pitch to Simmons, who promptly lined a single to center, scoring both runners. Two outs later, Hector Cruz lined one off the left field wall, which managed to elude both the left fielder and center fielder long enough for Cruz to cruise all the way around for a rare inside the park home run.
After Falcone prevented any San Diego scoring in the fifth-inning, St Louis had a little lightning in a bottle in the bottom half of the fifth. With two out, Kessinger lined another single to center, bringing Brock to the plate. Lou then took the future 1976 NL Cy Young Award winner deep - not quite deep enough to go over the wall - but deep enough to hit high off the top of the wall - then elude both the right fielder and center fielder long enough for Brock to streak all the way around for another rare inside the park home run - the second in as many innings for the Cardinals.
Each team added single tallies in the sixth-inning to close out the scoring: St Louis 7 - San Diego 4.
Falcone (5-5) went the distance, handing Jones (12-3) a rare loss. Jones would be mediocre the rest of the season (10-11) - however, he still led the NL in wins, which was good enough to win his first and only Cy Young Award - although eight other NL pitchers were more deserving. Happens all the time.
Meanwhile, this would prove to be the last time Lou Brock would experience the thrill of victory on his birthday. The Cardinals as a whole, had little to be thrilled about in '76 - except maybe this one game, featuring not one - but two inside the park home runs in successive innings. Yes indeed. Happy birthday, Mr Brock.
Monday, June 16, 2014
Niekro, Blyleven & Stieb - Flying Under the Cy Young Award Radar
How underrated was Phil Niekro? In three different seasons - 1974 - '78 - '79 - he posted the highest WAR among all National League pitchers - 7.8 - 10.0 - 7.6 - but never won a Cy Young Award.
In 1977, his 8.9 WAR was second only to Rick Reuschel's 9.4 - and neither of them won the CYA - it went to Steve Carlton, who posted a 5.9 WAR. Niekro, in fact, never even got a single vote that year.
For the entire decade of the '70's, Niekro and his knuckle-ball flew under the Cy Young Award radar, despite the fact that his 64.7 WAR for a pitcher was second only to Tom Seaver's 67.1 - a first ballot Hall of Famer.
Yet with all of his accomplishments throughout his long and illustrious career, Phil Niekro didn't even get enough votes for Cooperstown until his fifth try.
Bert Blyleven - another underrated great pitcher and prankster - had to wait nearly 15 years before he finally got in.
In 1973, his 9.9 WAR was tops in the American League, but in the CYA voting that year - the man with perhaps the greatest curve-ball in history - finished a distant seventh.
In the strike-shortened '81 season, Rollie Fingers won both the AL MVP and Cy Young Awards, with a 4.2 WAR. Blyleven's 5.6 WAR led the way for pitchers - yet received nary a CYA vote.
In '84, his 7.2 WAR was second only to Dave Stieb's 7.9 - and neither of them won the CYA - although Blyleven finished third - and Stieb - another highly underrated pitcher - finished seventh. Relief pitcher Willie Hernandez and his 4.8 WAR won it that year.
In 1989, at the advanced age of 38, Blyleven had the second highest WAR among AL pitchers - 6.0 - yet finished fourth in the CYA voting. At least this time, the pitcher with the highest WAR - Bret Saberhagen (9.7) - won the Cy Young Award. Imagine that.
Dave Stieb - at least for three straight seasons - may have been the most underrated pitcher in major league history. From 1982 to 1984, Stieb was the best pitcher in the American League, but never came close to winning a Cy Young Award. In 1982, however, The Sporting News named him Pitcher of the Year - an honor usually bestowed upon a Cy Young Award winner...
Stieb's greatest claim to fame came with having two no-hitters and one perfect game broken up in the ninth-inning - just one out shy of nailing down all three. No quitter - he finally got one on September 2, 1990 - the only one in Toronto Blue Jays history.
Time to examine another batch of Cy Young Awards. Niekro, Blyleven and Stieb had a lot of company in getting snubbed - including three rookies and a future Hall of Fame reliever who got snubbed as a starter - and should have been snubbed as a low-WAR reliever.
PART TWO - Revising CYA History (1976 - 1985) - 5 Out of 20 Correct Picks According to WAR
The year was 1976. A free-spirited Detroit Tigers rookie pitcher - Mark "The Bird" Fidrych - captivated the nation with his antics - most notably, his frequent in-game-on-the-mound conversations with baseballs - with explicit instructions on what he wanted them to do. Apparently, they listened.
Fidrych was not only the best pitcher in major league baseball in 1976, he was the best all-around player in the American League - period - with a 9.6 WAR as proof.
Coincidentally, in the National League, Joe Morgan was putting together his second straight MVP season with an identical 9.6 WAR.
However, Fidrych was runner-up to Jim Palmer (6.6 WAR) for the Cy Young Award, while Thurman Munson (5.3 WAR) won the Most Valuable Player Award.
Of course, The Bird took home the AL Rookie of the Year Award - with the highest WAR ever recorded by a rookie - until Mike Trout came along in 2012 - posting his astounding 10.8 WAR.
That same year - 1976 - San Francisco Giants pitcher - John "The Count" Montefusco - the '75 NL Rookie of the Year (6.4 WAR) - rejected any notion of experiencing a sophomore jinx in his second full season. His 6.9 WAR was the highest for any National League pitcher in '76 - but Randy Jones (4.8 WAR) took home the CYA - while The Count's CYA vote count was zero.
Here are the rest of the CYA winners (through '85) - along with evidence (if applicable) that indicates another pitcher deserved to win (more often than not):
1977 (AL) - Sparky Lyle (3.7) - Frank Tanana (8.3)
1977 (NL) - Steve Carlton (5.9) - Rick Reuschel (9.4)
1978 (AL) - Ron Guidry (9.6)
1978 (NL) - Gaylord Perry (4.3) - Phil Niekro (10.0)
1979 (AL) - Mike Flanagan (3.9) - Dennis Eckersley* (7.3)
1979 (NL) - Bruce Sutter (4.9) - Phil Niekro (7.6)
(*For Eckersley, who probably deserved to win the CYA in '79, this makes up for the one he'd get in '92 for no good reason.)
1980 (AL) - Steve Stone (4.0) - Britt Burns (7.0)*
1980 (NL) - Steve Carlton (10.2)
(*Burns was a Chicago White Sox rookie in 1980, and despite the high WAR, only finished 5th in the ROY voting.)
1981 (AL) - Rollie Fingers (4.2) - Bert Blyleven (5.6)
1981 (NL) - Fernando Valenzuela (4.8) - Steve Carlton (5.5)
1982 (AL) - Pete Vuckovich (2.8) - Dave Stieb (7.7)
1982 (NL) - Steve Carlton (5.5) - Steve Rogers (7.7)
1983 (AL) - Lamar Hoyt (3.7) - Dave Stieb (7.0)*
1983 (NL) - John Denny (7.4)
(*Stieb's reward for being the best AL pitcher in '82 without winning the CYA was to be completely snubbed by voters in '83 - despite once again, being the league's best pitcher.)
1984 (AL) - Willie Hernandez (4.8) - Dave Stieb (7.9)*
1984 (NL) - Rick Sutcliffe (3.9) - Dwight Gooden (5.5)**
(*Stieb's reward for being the best pitcher in the American League for the third straight year was a seventh place finish in this year's CYA race. Whoopee.)
(**Gooden was good enough to go back-to-back. See below.)
1985 (AL) - Bret Saberhagen (7.3)
1985 (NL) - Dwight Gooden (12.1)*
(*Gooden was so good in '85, he posted the highest WAR of any pitcher since the CYA was established in 1956.)
Up Next: Part Three (1986 - 1995) - Two More Overrated Closers & Other Surprises
In 1977, his 8.9 WAR was second only to Rick Reuschel's 9.4 - and neither of them won the CYA - it went to Steve Carlton, who posted a 5.9 WAR. Niekro, in fact, never even got a single vote that year.
For the entire decade of the '70's, Niekro and his knuckle-ball flew under the Cy Young Award radar, despite the fact that his 64.7 WAR for a pitcher was second only to Tom Seaver's 67.1 - a first ballot Hall of Famer.
Yet with all of his accomplishments throughout his long and illustrious career, Phil Niekro didn't even get enough votes for Cooperstown until his fifth try.
Bert Blyleven - another underrated great pitcher and prankster - had to wait nearly 15 years before he finally got in.
In 1973, his 9.9 WAR was tops in the American League, but in the CYA voting that year - the man with perhaps the greatest curve-ball in history - finished a distant seventh.
In the strike-shortened '81 season, Rollie Fingers won both the AL MVP and Cy Young Awards, with a 4.2 WAR. Blyleven's 5.6 WAR led the way for pitchers - yet received nary a CYA vote.
In '84, his 7.2 WAR was second only to Dave Stieb's 7.9 - and neither of them won the CYA - although Blyleven finished third - and Stieb - another highly underrated pitcher - finished seventh. Relief pitcher Willie Hernandez and his 4.8 WAR won it that year.
In 1989, at the advanced age of 38, Blyleven had the second highest WAR among AL pitchers - 6.0 - yet finished fourth in the CYA voting. At least this time, the pitcher with the highest WAR - Bret Saberhagen (9.7) - won the Cy Young Award. Imagine that.
Dave Stieb - at least for three straight seasons - may have been the most underrated pitcher in major league history. From 1982 to 1984, Stieb was the best pitcher in the American League, but never came close to winning a Cy Young Award. In 1982, however, The Sporting News named him Pitcher of the Year - an honor usually bestowed upon a Cy Young Award winner...
Stieb's greatest claim to fame came with having two no-hitters and one perfect game broken up in the ninth-inning - just one out shy of nailing down all three. No quitter - he finally got one on September 2, 1990 - the only one in Toronto Blue Jays history.
Time to examine another batch of Cy Young Awards. Niekro, Blyleven and Stieb had a lot of company in getting snubbed - including three rookies and a future Hall of Fame reliever who got snubbed as a starter - and should have been snubbed as a low-WAR reliever.
PART TWO - Revising CYA History (1976 - 1985) - 5 Out of 20 Correct Picks According to WAR
The year was 1976. A free-spirited Detroit Tigers rookie pitcher - Mark "The Bird" Fidrych - captivated the nation with his antics - most notably, his frequent in-game-on-the-mound conversations with baseballs - with explicit instructions on what he wanted them to do. Apparently, they listened.
Fidrych was not only the best pitcher in major league baseball in 1976, he was the best all-around player in the American League - period - with a 9.6 WAR as proof.
Coincidentally, in the National League, Joe Morgan was putting together his second straight MVP season with an identical 9.6 WAR.
However, Fidrych was runner-up to Jim Palmer (6.6 WAR) for the Cy Young Award, while Thurman Munson (5.3 WAR) won the Most Valuable Player Award.
Of course, The Bird took home the AL Rookie of the Year Award - with the highest WAR ever recorded by a rookie - until Mike Trout came along in 2012 - posting his astounding 10.8 WAR.
That same year - 1976 - San Francisco Giants pitcher - John "The Count" Montefusco - the '75 NL Rookie of the Year (6.4 WAR) - rejected any notion of experiencing a sophomore jinx in his second full season. His 6.9 WAR was the highest for any National League pitcher in '76 - but Randy Jones (4.8 WAR) took home the CYA - while The Count's CYA vote count was zero.
Here are the rest of the CYA winners (through '85) - along with evidence (if applicable) that indicates another pitcher deserved to win (more often than not):
1977 (AL) - Sparky Lyle (3.7) - Frank Tanana (8.3)
1977 (NL) - Steve Carlton (5.9) - Rick Reuschel (9.4)
1978 (AL) - Ron Guidry (9.6)
1978 (NL) - Gaylord Perry (4.3) - Phil Niekro (10.0)
1979 (AL) - Mike Flanagan (3.9) - Dennis Eckersley* (7.3)
1979 (NL) - Bruce Sutter (4.9) - Phil Niekro (7.6)
(*For Eckersley, who probably deserved to win the CYA in '79, this makes up for the one he'd get in '92 for no good reason.)
1980 (AL) - Steve Stone (4.0) - Britt Burns (7.0)*
1980 (NL) - Steve Carlton (10.2)
(*Burns was a Chicago White Sox rookie in 1980, and despite the high WAR, only finished 5th in the ROY voting.)
1981 (AL) - Rollie Fingers (4.2) - Bert Blyleven (5.6)
1981 (NL) - Fernando Valenzuela (4.8) - Steve Carlton (5.5)
1982 (AL) - Pete Vuckovich (2.8) - Dave Stieb (7.7)
1982 (NL) - Steve Carlton (5.5) - Steve Rogers (7.7)
1983 (AL) - Lamar Hoyt (3.7) - Dave Stieb (7.0)*
1983 (NL) - John Denny (7.4)
(*Stieb's reward for being the best AL pitcher in '82 without winning the CYA was to be completely snubbed by voters in '83 - despite once again, being the league's best pitcher.)
1984 (AL) - Willie Hernandez (4.8) - Dave Stieb (7.9)*
1984 (NL) - Rick Sutcliffe (3.9) - Dwight Gooden (5.5)**
(*Stieb's reward for being the best pitcher in the American League for the third straight year was a seventh place finish in this year's CYA race. Whoopee.)
(**Gooden was good enough to go back-to-back. See below.)
1985 (AL) - Bret Saberhagen (7.3)
1985 (NL) - Dwight Gooden (12.1)*
(*Gooden was so good in '85, he posted the highest WAR of any pitcher since the CYA was established in 1956.)
Up Next: Part Three (1986 - 1995) - Two More Overrated Closers & Other Surprises
Saturday, June 14, 2014
Cy Young Awards - Revisionist's History (1956 - 1975) Based on WAR
Before I begin my rant, I'm going to make a major assumption: The saber-metric geniuses who devised the formula for estimating a player's true value in wins created - Wins Above Replacement (WAR) - should be trusted. After all, according to WAR, players like Ruth, Williams, Mays and Mantle were usually at or near the top of the Wins Above Replacement heap, year in and year out - right where they belong.
WAR cuts through all the useless misinformation with one simple number that can be used to determine the best overall player in baseball - or, in the case of Cy Young Award voting - the best pitcher. Quite often, the best pitcher also happens to be the best overall player. Something voters tend to ignore when deciding Most Valuable Player Awards.
Much to my surprise, the pitcher with the highest WAR failed to win the Cy Young Award for the first seven years of its existence (1956 - '62). As a matter of fact, the pitcher who deserved the award wasn't even on the ballot the first six years! Chances are, they never even knew they deserved the award - but if they're still alive, maybe they'll find out through word of mouth. If you happen to run into them, congratulate them for me - although they still won't get the plaque. This is merely an unofficial adjustment, for the sake of Wins Above Replacement authenticity.
PART ONE - Revising CYA History - The Early Years (1956 - 1975)
Of course, over a half-century ago, nobody knew anything about WAR. Cy Young Award voters favored the pitchers from teams that won a pennant (or finished the regular season in a first-place tie), as long as they won 20 games. ERA didn't seem very important - just wins, and getting into the World Series. This process excluded the pitchers who actually had better seasons, but flew under the radar, with deceivingly mediocre won-loss records - playing on mediocre teams that didn't win. But it wasn't their fault - as their WAR numbers suggest.
Year - CYA Winner vs The Best Pitcher
1956 - Don Newcombe (4.5) - Early Wynn (7.8)
1957 - Warren Spahn (4.7) - Don Drysdale (6.1)
1958 - Bob Turley (3.6) - Frank Lary (6.7)
1959 - Early Wynn (2.8) - Larry Jackson (7.2)
1960 - Vernon Law (4.2) - Ernie Broglio (7.2)
1961 - Whitey Ford (3.8) - Don Cardwell (6.1)
1962 - Don Drysdale (5.3) - Bob Purkey (7.3)
1963 - Sandy Koufax (10.7)
1964 - Dean Chance (9.3)
1965 - Sandy Koufax (8.1)
1966 - Sandy Koufax (10.3)
1967 (AL) - Jim Lonborg (4.1) - Jim Merritt (6.4)
1967 (NL) - Mike McCormick (4.4) - Jim Bunning (7.8)
1968 (AL) - Denny McClain (7.4) - Luis Tiant (7.8)
1968 (NL) - Bob Gibson (11.9)
1969 (AL) - Tie: Mike Cuellar (4.5) and Denny McClain (8.2) - Just McClain (8.2)
1969 (NL) - Tom Seaver (7.2) - Bob Gibson (11.3)
1970 (AL) - Jim Perry (3.8) - Sam McDowell (8.3)
1970 (NL) - Bob Gibson (8.9)
1971 (AL) - Vida Blue (9.0) - Wilbur Wood (11.7)
1971 (NL) - Fergie Jenkins (10.3)
1972 (AL) - Gaylord Perry (11.0)
1972 (NL) - Steve Carlton (12.1)
1973 (AL) - Jim Palmer (6.3) - Bert Blyleven (9.9)
1973 (NL) - Tom Seaver (10.6)
1974 (AL) - Catfish Hunter (6.9) - Gaylord Perry (8.6)
1974 (NL) - Mike Marshall (3.1)* - Phil Niekro (7.8)
(*Marshall had the distinction of being the first erroneously selected CYA winner who was a relief specialist. Others would follow in years to come - all mistakes.)
1975 (AL) - Jim Palmer (8.4)
1975 (NL) - Tom Seaver (7.8)
Imagine that. Jim Merritt and Luis Tiant over Jim Lonborg and Denny McClain in '67 and '68. Or Wilbur Wood over Vida Blue - who made the cover of Time Magazine in 1971!
Believe it.
Up next: PART TWO - Revising CYA History - (1976 - 1985) - 5 Out of 20 Correct CYA Winners!
WAR cuts through all the useless misinformation with one simple number that can be used to determine the best overall player in baseball - or, in the case of Cy Young Award voting - the best pitcher. Quite often, the best pitcher also happens to be the best overall player. Something voters tend to ignore when deciding Most Valuable Player Awards.
Much to my surprise, the pitcher with the highest WAR failed to win the Cy Young Award for the first seven years of its existence (1956 - '62). As a matter of fact, the pitcher who deserved the award wasn't even on the ballot the first six years! Chances are, they never even knew they deserved the award - but if they're still alive, maybe they'll find out through word of mouth. If you happen to run into them, congratulate them for me - although they still won't get the plaque. This is merely an unofficial adjustment, for the sake of Wins Above Replacement authenticity.
PART ONE - Revising CYA History - The Early Years (1956 - 1975)
Of course, over a half-century ago, nobody knew anything about WAR. Cy Young Award voters favored the pitchers from teams that won a pennant (or finished the regular season in a first-place tie), as long as they won 20 games. ERA didn't seem very important - just wins, and getting into the World Series. This process excluded the pitchers who actually had better seasons, but flew under the radar, with deceivingly mediocre won-loss records - playing on mediocre teams that didn't win. But it wasn't their fault - as their WAR numbers suggest.
Year - CYA Winner vs The Best Pitcher
1956 - Don Newcombe (4.5) - Early Wynn (7.8)
1957 - Warren Spahn (4.7) - Don Drysdale (6.1)
1958 - Bob Turley (3.6) - Frank Lary (6.7)
1959 - Early Wynn (2.8) - Larry Jackson (7.2)
1960 - Vernon Law (4.2) - Ernie Broglio (7.2)
1961 - Whitey Ford (3.8) - Don Cardwell (6.1)
1962 - Don Drysdale (5.3) - Bob Purkey (7.3)
1963 - Sandy Koufax (10.7)
1964 - Dean Chance (9.3)
1965 - Sandy Koufax (8.1)
1966 - Sandy Koufax (10.3)
1967 (AL) - Jim Lonborg (4.1) - Jim Merritt (6.4)
1967 (NL) - Mike McCormick (4.4) - Jim Bunning (7.8)
1968 (AL) - Denny McClain (7.4) - Luis Tiant (7.8)
1968 (NL) - Bob Gibson (11.9)
1969 (AL) - Tie: Mike Cuellar (4.5) and Denny McClain (8.2) - Just McClain (8.2)
1969 (NL) - Tom Seaver (7.2) - Bob Gibson (11.3)
1970 (AL) - Jim Perry (3.8) - Sam McDowell (8.3)
1970 (NL) - Bob Gibson (8.9)
1971 (AL) - Vida Blue (9.0) - Wilbur Wood (11.7)
1971 (NL) - Fergie Jenkins (10.3)
1972 (AL) - Gaylord Perry (11.0)
1972 (NL) - Steve Carlton (12.1)
1973 (AL) - Jim Palmer (6.3) - Bert Blyleven (9.9)
1973 (NL) - Tom Seaver (10.6)
1974 (AL) - Catfish Hunter (6.9) - Gaylord Perry (8.6)
1974 (NL) - Mike Marshall (3.1)* - Phil Niekro (7.8)
(*Marshall had the distinction of being the first erroneously selected CYA winner who was a relief specialist. Others would follow in years to come - all mistakes.)
1975 (AL) - Jim Palmer (8.4)
1975 (NL) - Tom Seaver (7.8)
Imagine that. Jim Merritt and Luis Tiant over Jim Lonborg and Denny McClain in '67 and '68. Or Wilbur Wood over Vida Blue - who made the cover of Time Magazine in 1971!
Believe it.
Up next: PART TWO - Revising CYA History - (1976 - 1985) - 5 Out of 20 Correct CYA Winners!
Labels:
bob gibson,
Cy Young Award,
denny mcclain,
jim lonborg,
Jim Palmer,
mlb,
Phil Niekro,
sandy koufax,
tom seaver,
WAR
Saturday, December 8, 2012
Are Today's MLB Relievers Overrated & Overpaid?
What was the best season ever recorded by a reliever in major league history? Many baseball experts point to Dennis Eckersley's 1990 season when the Hall of Fame closer for the Oakland A's posted the lowest ERA ever for a reliever - 0.61 - while recording 48 saves in 73.1 innings of work. His ERA+ of 603 is so far off the charts, it's ridiculous. In fact, MLB Network recently aired a Prime Nine episode highlighting the Top Nine Reliever Seasons of All-Time, and this particular effort was ranked Number One.
Apparently, Prime Nine doesn't believe in all that saber-metrics stuff like the Baseball Reference.com Wins Over Replacement (WAR) measurement. But we do, and Eckersley's 3.2 WAR is good for 9th-place on this list. Strangely enough, Eric Gagne's 2003 season (MLB-record 55 straight saves) may be Number Two on Prime Nine, but is 8th over here. Go figure.
Here's how Gagne and the others fared (Prime Nine's rank in parenthesis) - In ascending order by WAR - along with ERA, IP, CYA & MVP voting.
2003 - Eric Gagne (2) - 1.20 ERA - 82.1 IP - 3.6 WAR (Won NL CYA)
1998 - Trevor Hoffman (8) - 1.48 ERA - 73.0 IP - 4.0 WAR (2nd NL CYA)
1984 - Willie Hernandez (9) - 1.92 ERA - 140.1 IP - 4.6 WAR (Won AL CYA & MVP)
1996 - Mariano Rivera (6) - 2.09 ERA - 107.2 IP - 4.8 WAR (3rd AL CYA)
1977 - Bruce Sutter (4) - 1.34 ERA - 107.1 IP - 6.5 WAR (6th NL CYA)
1986 - Mark Eichorn (7) - 1.72 ERA - 157.0 IP - 7.1 WAR (6th AL CYA)
1973 - John Hiller (3) - 1.44 ERA - 125.1 IP - 7.9 WAR (4th AL CYA)
1975 - Goose Gossage (5) - 1.84 ERA - 141.2 IP - 8.1 WAR (T-6th AL CYA)
Not that the baseball writers who vote on MVP and Cy Young Awards are dumb, but the guys at the top of this list had the lowest Wins Over Replacement calculations - yet the strongest support for postseason awards - whereas the guys like Eichorn, Hiller and Gossage - with exceptionally high WAR totals - hardly received any support at all. Go figure.
Of course, back in the '70s and '80s, the concept of Wins Over Replacement had yet to be developed. Voters typically gave the pitcher with the most wins the most CYA support - or in the case of relievers - an unusually high saves total. Of course, those numbers can be misleading; when Gossage saved 28 games in '75 (he also won 9), he often worked more than just an inning or two to secure the win. Many of the games he entered were in the middle innings with runners on base; his job was to put out the fire, then keep the other team at bay until the last out was recorded. Now those were real saves; it also explains why he pitched about twice as many innings as Eckersley, Gagne and Hoffman; and why his WAR was more than two times higher than those other guys. But what can be expected from part-time help; aside from multi-million dollar contracts?
It's nobody's fault; this is how the game is being managed today. The art of securing saves has become a joint effort, for the most part, often employing the services of a 7th-inning specialist, then the set-up man, then the closer. It's an efficient system, since having three fresh arms coming in to pitch the last thee innings or so to secure a win makes perfect sense. Of course, Gossage used to perform all three functions by himself, thank you very much. Doing it the old-fashioned Gossage way not only freed-up a couple of spots on the roster, it probably saved his team (Chicago White Sox) a little bit of money on payroll expense. Of course, in 1975, that didn't amount to much.
However, in 2013, just about everybody working in the bullpen will be making anywhere from a couple of million to $15 million per year. These salaries are skyrocketing because most front offices in MLB have bought into the notion that relievers (part-time employees) are actually worth as much, if not more than a starting pitcher or position player (full-time employees).
Saves are nice, of course. However, when they come by rather cheaply, their significance is overrated; and for teams looking to trim the payroll, there appears to be no relief in sight - just plenty of relievers.
Apparently, Prime Nine doesn't believe in all that saber-metrics stuff like the Baseball Reference.com Wins Over Replacement (WAR) measurement. But we do, and Eckersley's 3.2 WAR is good for 9th-place on this list. Strangely enough, Eric Gagne's 2003 season (MLB-record 55 straight saves) may be Number Two on Prime Nine, but is 8th over here. Go figure.
Here's how Gagne and the others fared (Prime Nine's rank in parenthesis) - In ascending order by WAR - along with ERA, IP, CYA & MVP voting.
2003 - Eric Gagne (2) - 1.20 ERA - 82.1 IP - 3.6 WAR (Won NL CYA)
1998 - Trevor Hoffman (8) - 1.48 ERA - 73.0 IP - 4.0 WAR (2nd NL CYA)
1984 - Willie Hernandez (9) - 1.92 ERA - 140.1 IP - 4.6 WAR (Won AL CYA & MVP)
1996 - Mariano Rivera (6) - 2.09 ERA - 107.2 IP - 4.8 WAR (3rd AL CYA)
1977 - Bruce Sutter (4) - 1.34 ERA - 107.1 IP - 6.5 WAR (6th NL CYA)
1986 - Mark Eichorn (7) - 1.72 ERA - 157.0 IP - 7.1 WAR (6th AL CYA)
1973 - John Hiller (3) - 1.44 ERA - 125.1 IP - 7.9 WAR (4th AL CYA)
1975 - Goose Gossage (5) - 1.84 ERA - 141.2 IP - 8.1 WAR (T-6th AL CYA)
Not that the baseball writers who vote on MVP and Cy Young Awards are dumb, but the guys at the top of this list had the lowest Wins Over Replacement calculations - yet the strongest support for postseason awards - whereas the guys like Eichorn, Hiller and Gossage - with exceptionally high WAR totals - hardly received any support at all. Go figure.
Of course, back in the '70s and '80s, the concept of Wins Over Replacement had yet to be developed. Voters typically gave the pitcher with the most wins the most CYA support - or in the case of relievers - an unusually high saves total. Of course, those numbers can be misleading; when Gossage saved 28 games in '75 (he also won 9), he often worked more than just an inning or two to secure the win. Many of the games he entered were in the middle innings with runners on base; his job was to put out the fire, then keep the other team at bay until the last out was recorded. Now those were real saves; it also explains why he pitched about twice as many innings as Eckersley, Gagne and Hoffman; and why his WAR was more than two times higher than those other guys. But what can be expected from part-time help; aside from multi-million dollar contracts?
It's nobody's fault; this is how the game is being managed today. The art of securing saves has become a joint effort, for the most part, often employing the services of a 7th-inning specialist, then the set-up man, then the closer. It's an efficient system, since having three fresh arms coming in to pitch the last thee innings or so to secure a win makes perfect sense. Of course, Gossage used to perform all three functions by himself, thank you very much. Doing it the old-fashioned Gossage way not only freed-up a couple of spots on the roster, it probably saved his team (Chicago White Sox) a little bit of money on payroll expense. Of course, in 1975, that didn't amount to much.
However, in 2013, just about everybody working in the bullpen will be making anywhere from a couple of million to $15 million per year. These salaries are skyrocketing because most front offices in MLB have bought into the notion that relievers (part-time employees) are actually worth as much, if not more than a starting pitcher or position player (full-time employees).
Saves are nice, of course. However, when they come by rather cheaply, their significance is overrated; and for teams looking to trim the payroll, there appears to be no relief in sight - just plenty of relievers.
Thursday, November 29, 2012
Chapman to Rotation Makes Sabermetric Sense
The Cincinnati Reds' plan to move lefty power-closer Aroldis Chapman and his 100 mph fastball into the starting rotation has drawn the ire of many baseball analysts, including MLB Network's Mitch "Wild Thing" Williams. For that reason alone, the decision makes sense, since the inaccuracy of "Wild Thing's" assessments and predictions is nearly 100%.
Aside from that compelling bit of logic, Chapman's transition from the bullpen to the starting rotation would potentially give Cincinnati around 200 innings pitched*, as opposed to the 71.2 he logged in 2012. Those extra innings - assuming they are "quality innings" - would translate into more wins for Cincinnati; a scary thought for the rest of the NL Central, considering the Reds already won 97 games in 2012.
*UPDATE: Word from the Reds' front office is that Chapman will be under an innings limit when he goes into the rotation. No word on what that innings limit will be, however.
The saber-metric evidence is compelling: Good starting pitchers are more valuable than even the elite relief specialists; sometimes, significantly more valuable. Observe the disparity in the ERA+ of Chapman over the top four starting pitchers in the 2012 NL Cy Young Award voting; then observe the disparity in the Wins Above Replacement (WAR) of the four starters over Chapman:
ERA+ WAR
Dickey - 140 5.6
Kershaw - 150 6.2
Gonzalez - 137 4.5
Cueto - 152 5.8
Chapman - 282 3.6
Chapman's ERA+ is roughly two times better than the four best starting pitchers in the National League; yet the limited use of his talents translates into fewer wins for his team than the other four. As an aside, it appears that either Kershaw or Cueto might have a stronger case for the CYA than Dickey; however, somebody else can write about that.
Historically, even when relief specialists get the nod for either the Most Valuable Player Award and/or the Cy Young Award, they don't compare favorably to other players in the voting mix, from a purely saber-metric perspective. Here's the evidence - the award winners who were strictly relief specialists - their WAR, their rank compared to other players receiving votes, and the player who actually had the highest WAR:
WAR Rank Highest Player
1950 - NL MVP Jim Konstanty (PHI) 4.2 16th 7.8 Eddie Stanky (NYG)
1974 - NL CYA Mike Marshall (LAD) 2.9 5th 7.5 Phil Niekro (ATL)
1977 - AL CYA Sparky Lyle (NYY) 3.5 9th 8.0 Frank Tanana (CAA)
1979 - NL CYA Bruce Sutter (CHC) 4.9 3rd 7.0 Phil Niekro (ATL)
1981 - AL MVP Rollie Fingers (MIL) 4.1 10th 6.6 Rickey Henderson (OAK) &
Dwight Evans (BOS)
1981 - AL CYA Rollie Fingers (MIL) 4.1 2nd 4.3 Steve McCatty (OAK)
1984 - AL MVP Willie Hernandez (DET) 4.6 14th 9.8 Cal Ripken (BAL)*
1984 - AL CYA Willie Hernandez (DET) 4.6 4th 7.6 Dave Stieb (TOR)
1987 - NL CYA Steve Bedrosian (PHI) 2.2 8th** 6.8 Bob Welch (LAD)
1992 - AL MVP Dennis Eckersley (OAK) 2.8 17th 8.4 Roger Clemens (BOS)
1992 - AL CYA Dennis Eckersley (OAK) 2.8 6th 8.4 Roger Clemens (BOS)
2003 - NL CYA Eric Gagne (LAD) 3.6 3rd 7.2 Mark Prior (CHC)
Notes: *Despite having the highest WAR in the AL in 1984 (before WAR was even devised), Cal Ripken garnered the grand total of ONE POINT in the MVP vote! **Steve Bedrosian (who saved 40 games) had the lowest WAR among all pitchers receiving NL CYA votes in 1987! Surely, there were others not receiving votes that had a higher WAR than Bedrock's 2.2.
The impact on MLB history may not seem significant if the players with the highest WAR actually won these awards, but it surely would've gotten Phil Niekro in the HOF sooner had he won both the '74 and '79 NL Cy Young Awards! Ironically, a knuckleball pitcher won the NL CYA this past season - RA Dickey - and it was the first time in MLB history that had happened; but it should've happened 38 years ago.
In the "borderline" case of Dwight Evans, perhaps winning the 1981 AL MVP Award would've put him over the top with the voters; he certainly belongs in Cooperstown. Hopefully, as they become more saber-metrically informed, worthy players like Evans will finally get their just rewards.
Although some may disagree with the evidence, it seems apparent that a great starting pitcher is comparable to a great everyday player, in terms of the value they provide for their team. The argument baseball analysts (like Mitch Williams) use when trying to dispel the notion that no pitcher should be considered for a Most Valuable Player Award - because they're not "everyday players" - is saber-metrically unfounded. Some of the highest WAR totals over the years belong to starting pitchers; just not relief pitchers.
Another compelling piece of evidence: The elite relief specialists obviously receive a lot of media attention for racking up a lot of saves; but it appears the "save" may be one of the most overrated statistics in MLB history. That probably explains why a fairly mediocre relief pitcher like Steve Bedrosian - with those 40 saves in 1987 - was able to capture the NL Cy Young Award that year. Strangely enough, the greatest closer ever - the New York Yankees' Mariano Rivera - never won a CYA, although he finished second once and third twice.
It's also interesting to note that for whatever reasons, no team has ever won a World Series with a closer that has recorded 50 or more saves; it's happened on nine different occasions, but has yet to help produce a World Championship for any team. Go figure.
That gets us back to the Aroldis Chapman debate. Quite simply, if he's able to still pitch effectively as a starter and give the Reds somewhere around 200 IP next season (assuming he stays healthy), he'll be helping them win more games, and that seems to be a gamble worth taking; a no-brainer, especially for a team with no left-handed starters currently in the rotation.
Taking it one step further, if Chapman even comes close to matching the level of performance he produced in 2012, the next NL Cy Young Award winner may well be a former flame-throwing, somersaulting, left-handed relief specialist currently employed by the Cincinnati Reds; who were smart enough to put him in a role that made saber-metric sense.
Labels:
aroldis chapman,
Cincinnati Reds,
Cy Young Award,
MVP Award,
saber-metrics,
WAR
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)